Note: This discussion is about an older version of the COMSOL Multiphysics® software. The information provided may be out of date.
Discussion Closed This discussion was created more than 6 months ago and has been closed. To start a new discussion with a link back to this one, click here.
To solve electric double layer between parallel plate
Posted 28 mars 2012, 04:24 UTC−4 Modeling Tools & Definitions, Parameters, Variables, & Functions, Studies & Solvers Version 4.3 2 Replies
Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam
Hi.
I'm trying to solve electric double layer between charged parallel plate using Nernst-Planck eqn & Poisson eqn
rather than Poisson-Boltzmann eqn. Because I want to research double layer overlap and flow in nano channel.
At first step, I tried to solve that system. left end is charged wall.
________zero charge________
---------------------------------------------
zero charge
Using 'transport of dilute species' and 'electrostatics' modules, I can solve electric double layer in that system. There
was no problem. However, see the next domain.
________charged wall________
---------------------------------------------
charged wall
In above situation which is corresponding charged nanochannel, I failed to solve electric double layer.
If COMSOL gives me some error message, I agree that my model is wrong. But there's no error, convergence is very nice.
In spite of that, result is very strange comparing to EDL structure in text book.
Why do I encounter this type of failure? My BCs are wrong?
Followings are my BCs;
at charged wall, surface charge density, qs (electrostatics)
no flux (transport of dilute species)
at ends of channel, ground (electrostatics)
bulk concentration, c0 for cation and anion (transport of dile species)
for initial condition, potential = 0 & concentration = c0 for cation and anion
Maybe I think there's no problem in my model, so I confused.
Please let me know how can I solve EDL in that system using NP eqn & Poisson eqn rather than Poisson-Boltzmann eqn.
Thanks.
I'm trying to solve electric double layer between charged parallel plate using Nernst-Planck eqn & Poisson eqn
rather than Poisson-Boltzmann eqn. Because I want to research double layer overlap and flow in nano channel.
At first step, I tried to solve that system. left end is charged wall.
________zero charge________
---------------------------------------------
zero charge
Using 'transport of dilute species' and 'electrostatics' modules, I can solve electric double layer in that system. There
was no problem. However, see the next domain.
________charged wall________
---------------------------------------------
charged wall
In above situation which is corresponding charged nanochannel, I failed to solve electric double layer.
If COMSOL gives me some error message, I agree that my model is wrong. But there's no error, convergence is very nice.
In spite of that, result is very strange comparing to EDL structure in text book.
Why do I encounter this type of failure? My BCs are wrong?
Followings are my BCs;
at charged wall, surface charge density, qs (electrostatics)
no flux (transport of dilute species)
at ends of channel, ground (electrostatics)
bulk concentration, c0 for cation and anion (transport of dile species)
for initial condition, potential = 0 & concentration = c0 for cation and anion
Maybe I think there's no problem in my model, so I confused.
Please let me know how can I solve EDL in that system using NP eqn & Poisson eqn rather than Poisson-Boltzmann eqn.
Thanks.
2 Replies Last Post 13 mai 2013, 15:12 UTC−4