Robert Koslover
Certified Consultant
Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam
Posted:
2 years ago
1 mai 2023, 13:13 UTC−4
I ran your model. The current density does not exhibit that behavior, if you look closely. (Try plotting a slice plot of the current density in a plane that bisects the loop.) Also, you might want to use a finer mesh on that coil, since in your model, nearly the entire cross-section of the wire is being represented by a single mesh element.
-------------------
Scientific Applications & Research Associates (SARA) Inc.
www.comsol.com/partners-consultants/certified-consultants/sara
I ran your model. The current density does not exhibit that behavior, if you look closely. (Try plotting a slice plot of the current density in a plane that bisects the loop.) Also, you might want to use a finer mesh on that coil, since in your model, nearly the entire cross-section of the wire is being represented by a single mesh element.
Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam
Posted:
2 years ago
1 mai 2023, 17:59 UTC−4
I ran your model. The current density does not exhibit that behavior, if you look closely. (Try plotting a slice plot of the current density in a plane that bisects the loop.) Also, you might want to use a finer mesh on that coil, since in your model, nearly the entire cross-section of the wire is being represented by a single mesh element.
Thanks Robert
Now, I got it.
>I ran your model. The current density does not exhibit that behavior, if you look closely. (Try plotting a slice plot of the current density in a plane that bisects the loop.) Also, you might want to use a finer mesh on that coil, since in your model, nearly the entire cross-section of the wire is being represented by a single mesh element.
Thanks Robert
Now, I got it.
Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam
Posted:
2 years ago
2 mai 2023, 15:22 UTC−4
I ran your model. The current density does not exhibit that behavior, if you look closely. (Try plotting a slice plot of the current density in a plane that bisects the loop.) Also, you might want to use a finer mesh on that coil, since in your model, nearly the entire cross-section of the wire is being represented by a single mesh element.
Thanks Robert
Now, I got it.
Hi Robert
I want to know how can I get current density vector that exists in any finite element? I have 2D axisymmetric version of same problem where only phi component of magnetic vector potential exists, r and z are zero. But in 3D model there are all three, though r and z are small. I believe the current density vector can only be near to phi direction, has r component. But z must be zero. I have attached 2D axisymmetirc version of same problem where it is visible that A has only phi component. Can you explain, why in 3D the other two components of A are also present.
(I have applied vector transformation to A in 3D and looking for A at inner surface of infinite domain).
>>I ran your model. The current density does not exhibit that behavior, if you look closely. (Try plotting a slice plot of the current density in a plane that bisects the loop.) Also, you might want to use a finer mesh on that coil, since in your model, nearly the entire cross-section of the wire is being represented by a single mesh element.
>
>Thanks Robert
>Now, I got it.
Hi Robert
I want to know how can I get current density vector that exists in any finite element? I have 2D axisymmetric version of same problem where only phi component of magnetic vector potential exists, r and z are zero. But in 3D model there are all three, though r and z are small. I believe the current density vector can only be near to phi direction, has r component. But z must be zero. I have attached 2D axisymmetirc version of same problem where it is visible that A has only phi component. Can you explain, why in 3D the other two components of A are also present.
(I have applied vector transformation to A in 3D and looking for A at inner surface of infinite domain).
Robert Koslover
Certified Consultant
Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam
Posted:
2 years ago
2 mai 2023, 16:31 UTC−4
You may be seeing numerical effects. To find out, see if the values change (for the small but non-zero components of A) if you use a finer mesh.
-------------------
Scientific Applications & Research Associates (SARA) Inc.
www.comsol.com/partners-consultants/certified-consultants/sara
You may be seeing numerical effects. To find out, see if the values change (for the small but non-zero components of A) if you use a finer mesh.