Discussion Closed This discussion was created more than 6 months ago and has been closed. To start a new discussion with a link back to this one, click here.
Referencing of variables and material properties in Version 5.2
Posted 24 nov. 2016, 10:58 UTC−5 Materials, Parameters, Variables, & Functions Version 5.2 3 Replies
Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam
Hello fellow Comsol-ians and Comsol-masters,
I am working with Comsol 5.2 for my Bachelor’s thesis and I am trying to model hydrogen flow through porous materials. I like it but I have a little problem:
so far, I have been unable to use dependent variables or defined material properties in my analytic functions, because Comsol says it cannot evaluate the variable. I have tried introducing the variable with some random value in the global Parameters, I have tried different syntax (along the lines of <name>.<variable_name> and the usual comp1.mat4.def.rho etc), but it refuses to work. Also, Comsol says it can’t evaluate comp1.T, which is really strange because it should know T! I mean, that’s the temperature! :-/
I wanted to attach my model, but I am getting a file extension error (it is only a small 192 kB .mph file) when I try to upload it here. But maybe you know the answer anyway? I would be very grateful for your help :-)
Greetings,
Sophie
I am working with Comsol 5.2 for my Bachelor’s thesis and I am trying to model hydrogen flow through porous materials. I like it but I have a little problem:
so far, I have been unable to use dependent variables or defined material properties in my analytic functions, because Comsol says it cannot evaluate the variable. I have tried introducing the variable with some random value in the global Parameters, I have tried different syntax (along the lines of <name>.<variable_name> and the usual comp1.mat4.def.rho etc), but it refuses to work. Also, Comsol says it can’t evaluate comp1.T, which is really strange because it should know T! I mean, that’s the temperature! :-/
I wanted to attach my model, but I am getting a file extension error (it is only a small 192 kB .mph file) when I try to upload it here. But maybe you know the answer anyway? I would be very grateful for your help :-)
Greetings,
Sophie
3 Replies Last Post 1 déc. 2016, 08:10 UTC−5
Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam
Posted:
8 years ago
Hi,
You can call an analytic function with a material property (such as mat1.def.rho) or a dependent variable (such as T) when you use it in your model to represent some part of the model's properties. In the definition of the analytic function, however, you use symbolic arguments to define the function's expression ("x", for example, as in the default settings). From the documentation: "Analytic functions have the ability to bind arguments during function calls. In other words, they do not require the actual argument names in an expression when writing the function. For example, you can define a function f(x) = x^2 with the input argument x and the expression x^2 and then call it as f(T), where T is the temperature in a heat transfer model."
Best regards,
Magnus Ringh, COMSOL
You can call an analytic function with a material property (such as mat1.def.rho) or a dependent variable (such as T) when you use it in your model to represent some part of the model's properties. In the definition of the analytic function, however, you use symbolic arguments to define the function's expression ("x", for example, as in the default settings). From the documentation: "Analytic functions have the ability to bind arguments during function calls. In other words, they do not require the actual argument names in an expression when writing the function. For example, you can define a function f(x) = x^2 with the input argument x and the expression x^2 and then call it as f(T), where T is the temperature in a heat transfer model."
Best regards,
Magnus Ringh, COMSOL
Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam
Posted:
8 years ago
Thank you very much, Magnus, for your fast help! I hadn't even thought that this could be the problem, but now it works!! :-)
Is it possible that you can't call upon an analytic function within another analytic function (both on the local level)? I was doing that, too, and am thinking now that it might have been another reason why it wasn't working.
Your help was (and is) much appreciated! :-)
Good day!
Sophie
Is it possible that you can't call upon an analytic function within another analytic function (both on the local level)? I was doing that, too, and am thinking now that it might have been another reason why it wasn't working.
Your help was (and is) much appreciated! :-)
Good day!
Sophie
Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam
Posted:
8 years ago
Hi again,
Yes, you can call one analytic function from another, keeping in mind to call it using a symbolic argument that is defined in the calling function. Also, you cannot have two analytic functions calling each other; doing so introduces a circular function dependency. Other than that, an analytic function call from another analytic function is supported and shouldn't be a problem.
Best regards,
Magnus Ringh, COMSOL
Yes, you can call one analytic function from another, keeping in mind to call it using a symbolic argument that is defined in the calling function. Also, you cannot have two analytic functions calling each other; doing so introduces a circular function dependency. Other than that, an analytic function call from another analytic function is supported and shouldn't be a problem.
Best regards,
Magnus Ringh, COMSOL